The Pros and Cons of Buying an Investment Property

A warm, practical look at the benefits and trade-offs of financing a new investment property, written for Gosford residents.

Hero Image for The Pros and Cons of Buying an Investment Property

Buying an investment property can build long-term wealth, but the loan structure you choose affects your cash flow from day one. If you are considering an investment property in Gosford, the decision usually comes down to how much borrowing you can comfortably carry.

This article covers the main advantages and drawbacks of an investment loan, so you can go into the conversation with a lender feeling prepared.

What Are the Main Pros of Buying an Investment Property?

The main advantages are the chance of capital growth, rental income that helps cover costs, and tax deductions on some holding costs. None of these is certain, because rents, values and your own circumstances can change.

Rental income can help cover the loan and ongoing costs. Interest on money borrowed to buy a rental property is generally deductible while the property is rented or available for rent. Council rates, insurance, property management fees, repairs and depreciation are also generally deductible. Only the interest part of a principal and interest repayment is deductible, not the part that pays down the loan. Please speak with your accountant about how this applies to you, as tax outcomes depend on your situation.

What Are the Cons and Risks of an Investment Loan?

The main drawbacks are that you carry the loan whether or not the property is rented, and that values can fall as well as rise. Costs such as repairs, body corporate levies and stamp duty add to the total outlay.

A gap in tenants means you still pay the loan. If you can't cover repayments for a period, it is worth knowing that lenders must consider hardship requests on regulated loans held by individuals. It is wiser to plan a buffer before you buy, such as savings or an offset account. The trade-off is that money sitting in a buffer isn't working elsewhere.

How Do Lenders Decide Your Investment Loan Amount?

Lenders work out your investment loan amount by testing whether you could still afford repayments if rates rose. Banks and other APRA-regulated lenders must assess new borrowers at a rate at least 3 percentage points above the loan's actual rate.

They also count only part of the expected rent. APRA's guidance is that prudent lenders include no more than 80 per cent of expected rent, to allow for periods when the property is empty. Your other debts, including credit card limits, also reduce what you can borrow. You can get a rough idea with our borrowing capacity page before you start looking at properties.

If you put down less than 20 per cent, the lender will generally ask for Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI). The premium is paid by you, and its cost varies with the loan amount and LVR. The trade-off is that you can buy sooner, but you pay extra and start with less equity.

Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance & Mortgage Broker at CoastFin today.

Interest Only or Principal and Interest: Which Suits an Investor?

Interest only keeps repayments lower for a set period, while principal and interest costs more each month but reduces your debt. Interest only does not increase how much you can borrow, because lenders assess you on the higher repayments over the remaining years.

Consider an illustrative example at 6.75% p.a. on a $500,000 loan over 30 years. Interest only repayments would be about $2,813 a month. Principal and interest repayments would be about $3,243 a month, which is around $430 more.

Now suppose the investor takes five years interest only, then moves to principal and interest. The loan balance is still $500,000, but it must now be repaid over the remaining 25 years. At the same illustrative rate, repayments become about $3,455 a month. That is roughly $210 a month more than if they had paid principal and interest from the start.

The outcome is that the investor enjoyed lower repayments early on, but faces a bigger jump later and has not reduced the debt in the meantime. These figures are illustrative only, and your rate will depend on your lender and deposit. A broker can run the numbers on your actual situation.

How Do the New Negative Gearing Rules Affect a Purchase?

The rules depend on when you buy and what you buy. Losses from properties held at 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 stay fully deductible against other income, as do losses from eligible new builds bought after that date.

For established residential properties bought after that time, the rules change from the 2027-28 income year. Net rental losses can then only be used against other residential property income, including capital gains on residential property. Excess losses can be carried forward. Properties bought between 12 May 2026 and 30 June 2027 can use the current rules until 30 June 2027 only.

Eligible new builds include homes built on vacant land, or replacing an existing dwelling where the number of dwellings increases. This can affect which property suits your plan, so check the details with your accountant before you commit.

Which Investment Loan Features Are Worth Paying For?

An offset account can reduce the interest you pay. Offset accounts may carry a fee or a different rate, depending on the lender, so check the product terms. It reduces the interest charged on the loan without changing the loan balance.

Fixed and variable rates also involve trade-offs. A variable rate moves with the market, which can help or hurt. Fixed loan features and break costs vary by lender, so check the product terms before choosing. Our investment loans team can compare the options from banks and lenders across Australia against your plans.

If you already own a property and plan to use its equity as a deposit, remember that interest is only deductible if the borrowed money is used for income-producing purposes. Borrowing against equity does not make the interest deductible on its own. It is also worth reviewing your existing loan through refinancing before you take on more debt.

Why Talk to a Local Broker Before You Make an Offer?

Speaking with a broker before you make an offer helps you know your limits, so you can act with confidence when the right property appears. You can also compare how different lenders treat rental income and deposits.

Our Gosford mortgage broker team works with Central Coast residents and can explain the trade-offs in plain language. Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you, and we will help you plan your next investment purchase.


Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance & Mortgage Broker at CoastFin today.